About Dave
Dave Gerhardt is the founder of Exit Five, a membership community for B2B marketing professionals. He previously served as CMO at Drift and Privy, where he built his reputation writing about marketing on LinkedIn and running a podcast on the side. He started what became Exit Five as a $10/month Patreon while still a CMO and reached $10,000 in monthly recurring revenue before ever going full time on it.
🎙️ Listen on YouTube, Apple Podcast, Spotify
Every company wants a community. Very few are willing to do what it actually takes to build one.
In this episode, I sat down with Dave Gerhardt to understand what separates Exit Five from the graveyard of dead Slack groups and what most B2B marketers get fundamentally wrong about storytelling, content, and building in public.
Here’s what I took away.
1) Most communities die because they're not the product. The companies building dead Slack groups aren't really building communities. They're building nurture sequences with a community skin. Dave's position: when a vendor owns the community, there's always an ulterior motive. Exit Five works because the membership is the business. There is no SaaS tool waiting at the end of the journey.
2) Charging money is a forcing function, not a cash grab. The two complaints Dave received from his Arizona CMO event came from the two people who had free tickets. Pricing signals commitment. It also filters out the people who would dilute the quality of the room.
3) The founder has to do the unscalable work first. Dave has written roughly 8,000 posts inside Exit Five and left 40,000 comments. He personally policed poorly written posts, tagged members with relevant expertise when a question went unanswered, and publicly praised the content worth celebrating.
4) Storytelling isn't a framework you can download. You can't prompt your way to taste. Dave's view: the marketers who are genuinely good at brand and storytelling have wide interests outside of marketing (music, food, design) and they're curious enough to steal from places nobody else is looking.
5) Using AI well is still slow work. Dave uses Claude to write his newsletter. It takes him two hours. He feeds it the transcript, past writing for reference, context on the guest, and asks it to come back with questions before it writes a single word. The output is better but it is not faster. AI slop is what happens when the subject matter expert leaves the room.
Where to find Dave: https://www.linkedin.com/in/davegerhardt/
Join Exit Five: https://exitfive.com/
Enjoy,
— Jordan
